Customer Reviews

As a small handmade business, we value honest feedback!

Please read what our customers have to say. If you have any questions or concerns, please send us a message.

Based on 20392 reviews
83%
(16856)
11%
(2211)
4%
(777)
1%
(305)
1%
(243)
L
Winter Sample Pack
Lisa S. (Bolton, CT)
Great scents but not strong

I absolutely love these scents but I prefer the scent to be stronger so I can actually smell the candles as they burn. I did not get that experience with these.

M
Scottish Ridge
Molly (Enfield, NH)
LOVE!!!!

This one is amazing. The strawberry is very strong when the candle is on lit, but the earthy scent of sage and moss come through when it’s burning to give it a sweet and woodsy scent. I cannot wait for this candle to be back so I can order more!

M
Castle Fire Demon
Molly (Enfield, NH)
Love it but wish it was stronger.

This smells fabulous prior to being lit, the clove being the heaviest scent unlit, but it doesn’t have enough carry in my living room, and that was disappointing, because I was excited about this one. The notes of cinnamon and fireplace are really lovely and this one. I just wish it was a little stronger.

S
Castle Fire Demon
Sarah N. (Jamestown, NC)
Great Candle!

I love the scent of this candle. It's perfect for burning on a dreary winter day.

M
Mystery Fragrance
M'lissa M. (Kalispell, MT)
Love the idea of this

I decided to do a couple of mystery candles because there are so few scents that I would regret getting, that I knew I was in for a treat. Also, it' was exciting not knowing what I would receive. I got one candle, Scottish Ridge, that I really wanted and loved it. I also got New Paperback, which would not have been one I would have sought out on my own, but it is still pretty nice and definitely has an accurate smell for it's title. I would definitely do the Mystery Candle again!

S
Crumpet's Eggnog
Sarah H. (Poughkeepsie, NY)
Fun seasonal scent!

Delicious! Love making the house smell like the holiday season!

S
Mystery Fragrance
Sarah H. (Poughkeepsie, NY)
Always love a discount!

Mystery candles are great especially when every scent from Frostbeard is great! You can’t miss!

S
Soldier Island
Sarah H. (Poughkeepsie, NY)
Great scent

I remember loving this scent way back in the day – so glad it came back!

S
Literati
Sarah H. (Poughkeepsie, NY)
What a fun scent!

These are all the scents I could ever ask for in a bookish candle!

S
To Be Read
Sarah H. (Poughkeepsie, NY)
Love!

I absolutely love this candle. Love the mix of the citrus and sage.

S
Wibbly Wobbly Timey Wimey
Sarah H. (Poughkeepsie, NY)
Just what your time machine needs!

If you don’t have a pot of tea to wake up your freshly regenerated doctor, this candle will do the trick!

S
Scottish Ridge
Sarah H. (Poughkeepsie, NY)
A delight!

Such a lovely scent! I hope they bring this candle back every year!

m
To Be Read
marissa (Babylon, NY)
I love it

This is a great smelling candle.

m
Babylon Candle
marissa (Babylon, NY)
I love it

I love this candle; it smells so good. Plus it is named after my home town, so I love it.

R
Headmaster's Office
Richard B. (Lyme, NH)
Great gift

Gift for my nephew studying great books. A big hit with him!

C
Winter Sample Pack
Chris H. (Vancouver, WA)
Wonderful scents

These scents are wonderful during a PNW winter. I use them in my office and the scents are relaxing for me but not overpowering to those who may be sensitive in the experience I have had here.

C
Mystery Fragrance
Cojie (Madison, WI)
Love it!

I ordered several different sizes, 9 in total. I appreciate that there were no duplicates! I didn't like the Wizardy Buttery Drink, it's kind of cloying, but had a friend who was super excited to take it. I liked all the others though, especially Marsh Girl! Mystery boxes are fun and the you can't beat the price point.

G
Mystery Fragrance
Gretchen J. (Hartsville, SC)
Mystery

It was awesome..love all your candles

c
Castle Fire Demon
cdcsmith (Norton, MA)
Love it!

I haven't actually lit the candle because I'm saving it for a specific occasion. I sniff it regularly though and I love it. There hasn't been a single purchase of a candle here that I have been disappointed by.

M
Mystery Fragrance
Melissa W. (Monroe, OH)
Fantastic Deal!

Loved both of my mystery candles! One was in perfect shape with the other having a small ding on the tin lid. Nothing that was an issue at all. I’ll have to get more next time!

L
To Be Read
LEAH P. (Chicago, IL)
Clean scent

Smells really refreshing, enjoyed it very much!

M
Mystery Fragrance
Molly R. (Norwalk, OH)
A fun gamble!

Mystery Fragrance is a fun way to try candle scents which I might not otherwise buy. I've purchase a few of these to keep on hand for gifts, but a couple of them I'm definitely keeping :)

J
Snow Maiden
Jay (Laurel, MD)
Well Balanced

I was concerned that this scent would be too sweet and cloying with the cranberries but I was pleasantly surprised to find that the sweetness of the cranberry is perfectly balanced by the woodiness of the winter birch. Throw is excellent with the wax melts.

J
Bah Humbug
Joan K. (Union City, NJ)
A Breath of Fresh Air

This takes me back to my winter hikes. The quiet and stillness of the trees, the crisp winter air, the hint of sunlight. I only wished I'd ordered the tin instead of the plastic-container melts.

J
Trail of Breadcrumbs
Joan K. (Union City, NJ)
Delightfully Cozy

I wasn't sure about the scent when I first opened the jar, but once it was burning, it was lovely. Makes me feel like I'm in front of a fire in a cottage in the autumn woods.