Mystery Fragrance

Regular price $37.00 Sale price$19.00 Save 49%
/

  • We pick the scent!
  • In stock, ready to ship
  • Backordered, shipping soon
Size

Get it between -

Free U.S. Shipping On Qualifying Orders
Secure Checkout Secure Payment
Free Replacements For Broken Items
High Quality Materials
  • 100% soy wax
  • Lead-free cotton wick
  • Premium fragrance oil
  • Vegan dye chips
Responsibly Made

Each item is poured by hand at our Minneapolis shop.

  • Soy wax is renewable, biodegradable, and vegan!
  • Containers are recyclable and reusable.
  • Fragrance oils are phthalate free.
8oz Jar
  • Container: Glass
  • Burn Time: 40+ hours
  • Volume: 8 fl oz
  • Net Weight: 14.8 oz
  • Size: 2.75" wide by 3.5" tall
4oz Tin
  • Container: Aluminum
  • Burn Time: 20+ hours
  • Volume: 4 fl oz
  • Net Weight: 4.4 oz
  • Size: 2.6" wide by 2" tall
2oz Tin
  • Container: Aluminum
  • Burn Time: 10+ hours
  • Volume: 2 fl oz
  • Net Weight: 1.8 oz
  • Size: 2" wide by 1.3" tall
Wax Melt
  • Container: Plastic
  • Volume: 2.75 fl oz
  • Net Weight: 3 oz
  • Cube Quantity: 6 per container
  • Cube Size: 1" wide by 1" tall
USE
  • Trim wick to 1/4" before each use.
  • Burn no longer than 2-3 hours at a time.
  • After use, cover with lid to reduce soot.
SAFETY
  • Burn within sight on heat-resistant surface.
  • Keep away from kids, pets and all flammable objects.
  • Discontinue use when 1/2" wax remains.
  • See our full list of safety tips!

Processing time is usually 1-2 days and shipping time is determined by your choice of postage at checkout.

All deliveries are carbon neutral. We partner with a service that measures our carbon footprint and pays credits towards long-term solutions that remove carbon from the atmosphere.

If you have any questions about shipping or your order, please contact us.

If you love surprises, you’ll love our Mystery Fragrance clearance items! You pick the size, we pick the fragrance, and you save 50%.

These clearance items are from our limited-run inventory, typically our previous Seasonal, “Bring it Back” and Candle of the Month collections. They are not part of our permanent collection or current seasonal inventory.

If you buy multiple items we will do our best to give you a variety of scents. Real products are not pictured. Some items may have minor surface imperfections, but most are in original condition. All sales are final – no returns or exchanges.

Handmade with Care

Sustainable

100% soy wax
No petroleum
Cruelty-free

Low waste

Poured in small batches
Carbon-neutral shipping
Reusable containers

High quality

Premium fragrance oils
Lead-free cotton wicks
Phthalate-free

Beloved by Bibliophiles

We stand by the quality of our products. Read what our customers have to say:

Customer Reviews

Based on 60 reviews
95%
(57)
2%
(1)
2%
(1)
2%
(1)
0%
(0)
A
Amy (Tower Hamlets, ENG)
So Fun

Frostbeard nailed it with this mystery scent! Somehow they knew I'd been wanting to try this candle for a while. It definitely had a similar vibe to the other candles I ordered, and it is actually my friend's favorite Frostbeard candle of all time. She wanted to steal it from me! They did a great job giving me a candle that I had never tried but knew I would love. Can't wait to get another mystery fragrance!

A
A.T. (Lincoln, CA)
Holy Heck

How did Frostbeard do it?! I ordered multiple mystery scents and an Oxford Library candle, and man did they pay attention! All the candles I received were ones I would have picked out myself! I love surprises, so it was so fun to get mystery candles!

M
Miranda H. (Milwaukee, WI)
Worth It

So I have never cared for Apple candles/scents and I don’t like peach. I ordered 3 (because what a deal!) and against all odds 2 had apple in them and 1 was peachy. HOWEVER these are the first apple scented candles I have ever liked, and the peach one I gave to a friend. They’re not real sweet or artificial smelling at all. I am obsessed with Call the Wind now and I never would have picked it before. Highly recommend

C
C.W. (Durham, NC)
First Disappointing Order from Frostbeard

I’ve never had a Frostbeard candle I didn’t like. That’s why when I got an email that they were offering 50% of of mystery candles, I jumped on the deal! I bought two candles for the price of one ($24 is STEEP for a small candle). I got Wordsmith and Never Never Lagoon. Both candles smelled good upon opening, but there’s no throw at all once lit. You have to be right above the candle to smell anything at all, and even then, the scent is hot wax + fire + barely any fragrance.

I wonder if this is the nature of these two candles, if they’re not strong because they’re old (and that’s why they were discounted), or if Frostbeard’s quality has waned. I’m deeply disappointed in these candles, and I wish I hadn’t spent $24 + shipping on these.

The mystery candles are from our previous scent collections, but the products themselves are recently made and contain the recommended amount of fragrance oil. I've sent you an email with some solutions so we can figure this out :)

L
Lauren L. (Chicago, IL)
Love Frostbeard!

I love these candles and I love the fun surprise of a mystery candle!

Count on us for

Fast & safe Shipping

Candles are heavy and fragile, but we're great at packaging them up safely. If any item breaks in the mail, we'll replace it for free.


Recently viewed