Customer Reviews

As a small handmade business, we value honest feedback!

Please read what our customers have to say. If you have any questions or concerns, please send us a message.

Based on 19279 reviews
83%
(15967)
11%
(2070)
4%
(735)
1%
(282)
1%
(225)
J
Reading at the Cafe
JLB (Slatedale, PA)
Best of the Bunch

I bought a bunch of candles recently on a lark and this one is the absolute best. I haven't even burned it yet and I can't stop smelling it. I wish there was a more portable version of the scent so I could put it in my car. It would be a great stress diffusing scent for after work. It's all of the best parts of chocolate and coffee without having to eat them(which I'd probably do anyway).

A
A Series of Fortunate Scents
Ariel E. (Houston, TX)
Delightful, a word which here means -

the refreshing grassy and floral notes mingle perfectly with freshly printed definitely-not-counterfeit money and a tinge of foreboding…on second thought, the foreboding might not be from the candle. Carry on! 10/10 candle

A
Smart Wizards
Ariel E. (Houston, TX)
Scent beyond measure is our greatest treasure!

WOW! I love all of Frostbeard’s candles but this one really takes the cake, I love it even more than my Sherlock’s Study candle which was my favorite until now. Wish I could bathe in this, 10/10!!

A
Brave Wizards
Ariel E. (Houston, TX)
Griff-IN Vogue

Vanilla goodness in a jar! I’d be Lion if I said I didn’t love it :)

A
Ambitious Wizards
Ariel E. (Houston, TX)
Slither in to a new scent!

This company does not disappoint - this and the Smart Wizards are my favorite of the 4 :)

A
Headmaster's Office
Ariel E. (Houston, TX)
Officially Wonderful

This sweet lemony candle is fit for the best of headmasters!

A
Divination Classroom
Ariel E. (Houston, TX)
A divine divination scent!

One of my favorite candles ever, so fragrant and the customer service is the best too!

M
Le Cirque des Rêves
Mary C. (Georgetown, KY)
Year after year best

I wait for the fall to get this candle every year. It's my favorite, it's my daughter's favorite so there are many purchased before they disappear. It smells like fall and adventure and magic. Really, it's the best scent, it has an amazing throw and it makes us all happy. Great candle.

M
Bearshifter
Mary C. (Georgetown, KY)
Different

I was certain I was going to like this even though it was new. So sure was I that I bought the 8 oz instead of the 4 oz. All the things in the candle, the honey, the oak, firewood and vanilla are things I love but it turns out that the mixture ends up not really smelling like any one thing. I'm sending it to the office with my hubby and I'm sure that someone there will love it. Not every candle scent is for everyone so I'm sure people will like this, it just fell flat for me.

J
The Inklings
Jessica (Moose Jaw, SK)

An excellent bookish fall scent. Smoky and slightly sweet. Wish the cider smell was a little stronger though.

J
Call the Wind
Jessica (Moose Jaw, SK)
Fall in a Jar

This candle smells like fall in a jar. Reminds me of being at university when all the trees would start to turn colours and you could smell the crisp autumn breeze. Refreshing, slightly sweet and absolutely perfect!

J
Candle of the Month - 12 Month Subscription
Judith S.N. (Santa Clara, CA)
Best gift to send and receive

My daughter gifted me a subscription for Christmas and I love it! When her own subscription expired I gifted her another year. Win/win for both of us.

J
Old Books
Jessica (Los Angeles, CA)
A favorite

I Iove this scent so much. It's a favorite for cozy evenings.

J
Call the Wind
Jessica (Los Angeles, CA)
Fresh and clean

A wonderful fresh and clean scent

J
Spooky Stories
Jessica (Los Angeles, CA)
Love it

Smells like a cozy evening reading spooky stories under a blanket. Absolutely love it!

A
The Old Forest
Angela C. (New York, NY)
Earthy, woodsy scent

Rich, earthy scent. Pleasant, and unlike any other fragrance I've smelled.

A
Call the Wind
Angela C. (New York, NY)
A new favourite

Hints of apple and wood - very fresh and crisp, like a cool Autumn morning. A subtle scent; not overpowering. I will definitely be buying more of this one.

H
Call the Wind
Hayley M. (Parsippany, NJ)
Fresh

This is a lovely fresh apple scent. It's got really great throw. I am really enjoying this one.

A
Spooky Stories
Allison (Washington, DC)
Lovely chocolate!

This is a good scent, but it is a fantastic scent if you love chocolate. That's the predominant scent that I get (which is nice!) with just a hint of leaves and campfire that makes it slightly musty. It fills the room and is a lovely fall scent, but if you don't like chocolate this might not be the scent for you.

Fun surprise

I love getting a new candle every month. It’s a nice surprise and let’s me alternate without getting tired of one scent. In the past I had missed a few of the new scents and now I’m not which is great.

K
Spooky Stories
Kathleen N. (Portland, OR)
Perfect combination of scents

Before I lit this one, I was afraid it would be way too strong for me, but it turns out to be just lovely. I like to burn it at night while I read in bed, and I often combine it with other fallish scents, like Dragon's Lair.

K
Sherlock's Study
Kathleen N. (Portland, OR)
Not as strong as I feared

When I first bought this, I decided to give it to a friend who loves Sherlock Holmes. I smelled it unburnt before I gave it to her, and it was very strong. It ran out, so I didn't buy another one for over a year, and I was nervous about it. It turns out to be very pleasant and not too strong at all. My son says it smells like cookies. I think it smells a touch like coffee, but not so pungent. I have been burning it with my fall scents, and it's a beautiful combination.

K
Dragon's Lair
Kathleen N. (Portland, OR)
I'd be happy if this were the only scent they had

I love how smooth and creamy this candle is. I've been burning it as my fall night scent, but it's lovely during the day, too. I like to combine it with Spooky Stories. While perfect for fall, I would enjoy this scent any evening and most days.

K
The Inklings
Kathleen N. (Portland, OR)
This is my favorite fall scent

If I had to pick one scent for fall, it would be this. Dragon's Lair is a close second, but I prefer to burn that one at night and this during the day. It blends well with spice-scented candles, too.

K
Pumpkin Juice
Kathleen N. (Portland, OR)
Perfect for fall

No surprise a spiced pumpkin candle is perfect for fall, but I don't like food-flavored candles, so I was a bit anxious about liking this one. As it turns out, it is not too foody, and it blends well with a host of other candles, including Sherlock's Study and Spooky Stories.